Buyer-Led
6 min read

How Do You Win a B2B Deal When You're Not the Favorite?

Magnus Willumsen
Co-Founder & CEO
November 18, 2026

You win by knowing the buyer better than the favorite does. 68% of B2B buyers have a favorite vendor before they talk to sales, and the favorite wins 55% of purchases. The other 45% tend to go to the seller who knows the buyer best. Four questions are a good place to start, answered in the buyer's own words: what the pain under the ask is, what each person in the buying group needs, why they have to act now, and what has to happen before they can buy.

This post is based on my talk at the B2B Sales Executive Network at Epicenter in Oslo, November 2026.

How often does the favorite vendor win a B2B deal?

More often than not. In Forrester's 2025 Buyers' Journey Survey, 68% of B2B buyers had a favorite vendor at the start of their buying process, before the first sales meeting. Buyers who start with a favorite choose it 80% of the time (Forrester). Across all purchases, the vendor the buyer preferred on day one wins 55% of the time (Forrester).

6sense's 2026 survey of 4,611 buyers points the same way: the eventual winner was on the buyer's first shortlist 92% of the time (6sense, via MarTech Edge).

Two things make the favorite harder to beat:

  • More people decide. The average purchase involves 13 people inside the buyer's company and 9 outside it, and 73% involve three or more departments (Forrester).
  • Buyers trust sellers less. 82% of buyers trust their own coworkers and management (Forrester). 45% trust sellers (LinkedIn).

Can you win if you're not the preferred vendor?

Yes. If the favorite wins 55% of purchases, 45% go to someone else. For startups and smaller companies, starting behind is the normal position.

One of our own deals this fall: the head of sales at a software company with around 70 people had been sent out to find something like one particular competitor. His team had tried it and liked it. We kept asking what was underneath. Their sales cycles run well over a year, and when a decision maker on the customer's side changes, they have to restart the deal because the history is scattered across notes. We showed him how we handle exactly that, inside the tool his team already uses. He chose us. The favorite had a head start. We knew the buyer better.

What should you know to beat the favorite?

This list isn't everything worth knowing about a deal. These are four questions that matter in almost every one, and you want the answers in the buyer's own words. Every sales methodology covers them. Few sellers can answer all four for their biggest open deals.

1. What is the pain under the ask?

The first request is rarely the real problem. Ask why until you reach a problem the whole company feels:

  • "We need better meeting notes."
  • Why? "Reps forget what the customer said between meetings."
  • Why? "Follow-ups go out late and sound generic."
  • Why? "Deals go quiet after the second meeting, when new people join."
  • Why? "We've missed forecast two quarters running. The board wants a plan by January."

Stop at the first answer and you are selling meeting notes like every competitor. Keep going and you are solving a forecast problem with a board deadline.

Another real example: an industrial company asked us for more time with new customers. Underneath, their prices had dropped, so they needed twice as many customers to keep revenue flat.

2. What does each person in the buying group need?

Each person wants something different, and you need to know what. In a Gartner survey of 632 B2B buyers, 74% said their buying team had unhealthy conflict during the purchase (Gartner). When that dysfunction is low, buyers are 13 times more likely to report a high-quality deal (Gartner).

Ask each person what a good outcome looks like, then show the group where they agree. The CFO hears the numbers. The team hears how their week gets easier. Avoid tailoring everything to your one contact: Gartner found that relevance to a single person reduced consensus by 59%.

3. Why do they have to act now?

Because waiting costs them something they can name. Many stalled deals end in no decision. The pain is real, nobody blocks, and nothing happens because nothing gets worse.

These sound urgent but cost nothing to delay:

  • "We want this in place by summer."
  • "Our new CEO wants to look at this."
  • "We have budget for this."

These are urgent, because waiting costs them:

  • "The new rules apply from 1 July." Miss it and they are not compliant.
  • "The board wants a plan by January." Someone is waiting for an answer.
  • "We lose two deals a month to this." Every month of waiting costs two more.

Ask: "Why now, and not in six months?" If there is no answer, there is no urgency yet.

4. What has to happen before they can buy?

A blocker is something in the buyer's own process that has to happen first, even if they want you. A discount won't move it. Four from our own deals this year:

  • Approval. The founder gives the final yes. Give your contact what the founder needs to see.
  • Another project. Their CRM rebuild comes first. Agree when to come back, and ask what would move you up the list.
  • An existing contract. They are locked into a vendor until year-end. Time the decision to the renewal date, or offer a free overlap.
  • A reorganization. The sales team is being reorganized first. Find out who owns the decision afterwards.

Where does AI help sellers know their buyers?

In remembering. Four answers, for several people per deal, across every open deal, changing after every conversation, is more than anyone can keep in their head. When sellers lose track, they fall back on pitching features.

AI's first job in sales was volume: more emails, more sequences. Three in four sellers in LinkedIn's survey of 900 say high-volume, untargeted outreach erodes buyer trust (LinkedIn). The more useful job is capturing what each buyer says and bringing it back before your next move. Gartner found that sales organizations giving sellers AI-enabled next best actions are 2.6 times more likely to achieve commercial growth (Gartner).

What did our own buyer meetings show?

That we had our top objection wrong. We had AI sort every objection from our 2026 buyer meetings by theme and company size. We assumed price. Price came up least at every company size. Fit came up about three times as often: does this work with the tools we already use?

No single seller saw it, because each deal felt like a price conversation. The pattern only showed up across all of them.

How can you start this week?

  1. Capture every interaction. Record your meetings, tell buyers why, and keep the emails. You want the buyer's own words.
  2. Check each buyer before you follow up. Ask AI: "What do we know about this buyer's pain, people, urgency and blockers? What is my next step?"
  3. Look across all your buyers once a month. Ask AI: "What does each type of buyer care about most, by role, size and industry?" Use the answer in your pitch and your outreach.

Where Scalign fits

Scalign captures every buyer interaction and helps you make the best next move in each deal. It records and makes sense of your sales meetings, then builds a Company Playbook for each account with the pains, the buying committee and the reasons to buy. Suggested Moves gives you the best next move for each deal, based on what that deal needs. See how it works.

Are you a Buyer Whisperer?

Take the seller self-check to see which of five levels you are at, and the one move that takes you up a level.

Frequently asked questions

What percentage of B2B buyers have a preferred vendor before contacting sales?

68%, according to Forrester's 2025 Buyers' Journey Survey. 6sense found the eventual winner was on the buyer's first shortlist 92% of the time.

How do you beat an incumbent or preferred vendor?

Know the buyer better than the favorite does. Four good places to start: find the pain under the ask, learn what each person in the buying group needs, confirm what it costs them to wait, and help clear what has to happen before they can buy. 45% of purchases go to a vendor who was not the favorite at the start.

What is the difference between an objection and a blocker?

An objection is doubt about you: price, product or fit. A blocker is a step in the buyer's own process, like an approval, another project, an existing contract or a reorganization. A discount can answer an objection. It rarely moves a blocker.

How do you find real urgency in a B2B deal?

Ask: "Why now, and not in six months?" Real urgency is a cost of waiting the buyer can name, like a compliance deadline, a board request or deals lost every month. If they can't name one, the deal may belong to next year.

Sources

Make what your best rep knows visible to the whole team.

Scalign turns every buyer conversation into the next step your team should take.

See how Scalign works →